Blog

Change management frameworks in practice: The strengths and limits of ADKAR, Kotter, and McKinsey

Written by Elina Lantto | Senior Change Consultant | 11/20/26, 6:47 AM

Change management frameworks such as Prosci ADKAR, Kotter and McKinsey’s Influence Model bring clarity and structure to change management. Yet organizations continue to encounter the same challenges: unclear objectives, conflicting incentives, and changes that fail to become embedded in everyday work. Why? In my experience, the decisive factor is not simply which framework you choose, but how its principles are reflected in leadership and practical decision-making.

A framework does not lead change

I have worked on transformation initiatives in international organizations and Finnish companies for more than 15 years, including over a decade as a change management professional. I’ve been involved in mergers, large-scale IT and cybersecurity transformations and, in recent years, the development of AI strategies and AI transformations.

Across these very different types of change, I have found that an organization’s size, its leaders' experience, or the resources available do not automatically guarantee successful change management. Shared objectives, clear responsibilities, and systematic monitoring can be lacking even in major initiatives.

Well-known frameworks provide a common language for leading change and help identify the conditions needed for success. However, they are not all alike, nor are they necessarily alternatives to one another. Their strengths complement each other when they are applied to the right questions.

Often, the problem is not a lack of methods, but the fact that those methods remain disconnected from day-to-day leadership.

A framework is a tool. The success of change depends on how the organization uses it and on the conditions it creates for people and ways of working to evolve.

Prosci ADKAR helps lead individual change

In transformation initiatives, I have often encountered the question of how to get people who resist change to change their behavior if they simply do not want to.

I would start from a different angle: why does a person not want to change the way they work? Do they lack understanding, belief in the benefits, or the opportunity to work in a new way?

This is where I believe Prosci’s ADKAR model is at its best. Its five elements – Awareness, Desire, Knowledge, Ability and Reinforcement – help identify the different conditions and barriers that influence individual change.

A person may understand why change is needed but be reluctant to give up their current way of working. Someone else may be motivated but lack the necessary skills or the time to practice. These situations require different solutions.

The strength of ADKAR lies in its clarity. It helps us understand why an individual’s behavior is not changing and what kind of support they need. Understanding the reasons behind resistance to change can also reveal valuable information about how the transformation has been designed and implemented.

The broader Prosci methodology shows what needs to change across the organization

Understanding individual change alone is not enough. If the barriers to change are conflicting objectives, ineffective processes, or insufficient leadership support, measures aimed at individuals will not solve the problem.

This is where the broader Prosci methodology complements the ADKAR model by providing a structure for planning, leading, and monitoring change at the organizational level. One of its key strengths is its business-driven approach: change management activities are linked to the targeted business benefits and the changes in ways of working required to achieve them.

This requires clear objectives and fact-based monitoring. Prosci’s PCT Model and organizational change readiness assessments can be used to identify the conditions and risks associated with successful change. ADKAR, in turn, can also be used to assess the change readiness and progress of individuals and employee groups. This provides management with information that can be used to steer the change, rather than merely reviewing it afterward.

Another key Prosci principle is active and visible leadership ownership, or sponsorship. I have seen situations where leaders participate in developing the strategy and launching the transformation, but then step back. The project organization and managers are left to resolve conflicting objectives, overlapping initiatives, and resource shortages without sufficient support from senior leadership.

True ownership means continuous decision-making, removing obstacles, leading by example, and monitoring the progress of the change. Managers, in turn, need the time and support to translate strategic objectives into everyday ways of working.

Leadership commitment is particularly tested when it comes to prioritization. If AI transformation is introduced as a new strategic priority while all previous initiatives remain unchanged, the organization may exceed its capacity to implement change.

If leaders do not decide what will no longer be done, they have not truly prioritized the change.

Prosci brings together an understanding of individual change and a structured, business-driven approach to managing transformation. However, no methodology can make strategic choices, resolve competing priorities, or demonstrate leadership commitment on an organization's behalf.

Kotter's model emphasizes shared vision and direction

The strengths of Kotter’s eight-step model include its emphasis on a shared vision, a guiding coalition, and participation.

While preparing for a major transformation, I discussed its objectives with members of the company’s executive team. There were almost as many different objectives and interpretations of the purpose of the transformation as there were members of the team.

Everyone considered the change important. However, there was no shared understanding of the primary objective or how success would be measured.

An executive team does not need to agree on everything. But it does need to address differences in perspective, agree on shared objectives, and commit to implementing the choices that have been made.

A shared decision does not necessarily mean shared understanding. And shared understanding does not guarantee the commitment or capability needed to turn that decision to action.

This is where the value of Kotter’s thinking becomes particularly clear. A group capable of leading change is not created simply by appointing one. It is built through shared direction, commitment, and concrete action.

A change management professional can help leaders make differences in perspective visible and clarify objectives before the transformation even begins. However, leaders themselves must make the necessary decisions and agree on priorities.

McKinsey helps identify conflicts between transformation and the current state

McKinsey's Influence Model considers four factors that influence change: 

  • understanding the meaning and purpose of the change,
  • leadership role modeling,
  • developing skills and capabilities,
  • structures and practices that support the desired behaviors.

The model’s strength lies in helping organizations identify situations in which their stated objectives conflict with the factors that actually shape people’s behavior.

Ultimately, the question is this: has the organization created the right conditions for change to succeed?

A manager, for example, may be expected to encourage the adoption of AI and develop their team’s capabilities while their own performance is measured solely on the short-term efficiency of existing operations.

The issue, then, may not be unwillingness to change, but conflicting expectations and incentives.

In my experience, incentives and rewards receive surprisingly little attention even in major transformations. What are leaders, managers and employees rewarded for? For renewal and learning, or only for the efficiency of current operations?

We cannot expect people to embrace new ways of working if the organization’s performance measures and incentives continue to reward business as usual.

The answer is not necessarily to abandon existing performance measures, but to complement them with objectives that support renewal. Organizations need to manage current performance while building future capabilities at the same time.

What do change management frameworks offer in the age of AI and continuous change?

Frameworks help structure the various challenges involved in leading change, but their strengths and limitations become particularly apparent in rapidly changing environments.

Prosci combines an understanding of individual change with business-driven and systematic change management. Its strengths include change planning, active leadership ownership, and goal-oriented monitoring. In AI-driven transformations, the challenge is to apply the methodology flexibly, as ways of working, capability requirements, and the benefits being pursued are constantly evolving.

Kotter helps create a shared strategic direction, build a coalition to drive change and strengthen commitment. In the AI transformation, however, the final destination may not always be known in advance. Leaders need to maintain a shared direction even as solutions evolve through experimentation.

McKinsey’s Influence Model helps identify how leadership, capabilities and incentives shape people’s behavior. However, it does not in itself explain how business processes, roles and responsibilities, or new AI-enabled services should be designed.

Change management frameworks are no less relevant in the age of AI. If anything, the clarity and structure they provide are becoming more valuable. The challenge is to apply them with sound judgment and flexibility as technologies, ways of working, and business priorities continue to evolve.

Change management frameworks provide structure, but lasting change capability is built in everyday work

Change management frameworks provide valuable structure, clarity, and a common language for leading change. They can also support the development of organizational change capability when their principles are embedded in everyday leadership and ways of working. However, lasting change capability requires more than the adoption of a framework: it depends on how an organization makes strategic choices, enables people to work differently, and learns from experience.

Lasting change capability develops through the way an organization leads renewal, makes strategic choices, identifies new opportunities, and learns from previous experiences.

At Digia, we also examine this broader picture through our change capability diamond, which is based on broad research. It helps identify the factors related to leadership, people, culture and structures that either support or slow down renewal. Digia’s Prosci-certified change management expertise, in turn, helps organizations apply change management methods to real-world situations.

When the next major change begins, the question is not only what will change. Equally important is how the change will be led, and whether the organization has learned from its previous transformations.

 

Want to know more?

Explore our services and get in touch. We help build change-capable organizations.